Life Insurance Retirement Plans: LIRP vs. Traditional Plans

Life Insurance Retirement Plans: Saving enough for a comfortable retirement is getting harder. With limits on 401(k) contributions, disappearing pensions, and market volatility impacting investment returns, you may wonder if you’ll ever be able to retire.

What if I told you there’s an under-utilized asset that can help bridge the retirement savings gap? It’s permanent life insurance.

Life insurance is typically purchased to protect loved ones financially if the policyholder dies. However, certain policies build up cash value that can be borrowed from or withdrawn during retirement. Used strategically, life insurance allows savers to supplement their retirement funds.

This post will explain everything you need about using life insurance for retirement planning.

What Is a Life Insurance Retirement Plan (LIRP)?

A life insurance retirement plan (LIRP) leverages permanent life insurance to supplement retirement savings. A LIRP is simply a whole life, universal life, or variable life insurance policy used to generate income in retirement.

These permanent policies have two key features that facilitate retirement planning:

Cash Value Savings
Lifetime Death Benefit

Cash Value – A portion of the premiums paid into the life insurance policy gets deposited into a cash value account. This savings component earns interest based on market performance or a fixed rate. Throughout the policy, the cash value account grows on a tax-deferred basis.

Death Benefit – Permanent life insurance policies pay out a lump sum to named beneficiaries upon the insured’s death, known as the death benefit. This can replace income for surviving dependents.

Access to tax-advantaged cash value growth and guaranteed death benefit coverage makes permanent policies a versatile option for funding retirement. Policyowners can take tax-free loans or withdrawals from cash value as supplemental retirement income.

The death benefit and cash value components remain intact as long as outstanding loans get repaid, and withdrawals don’t excessively drain the cash account. This dual-purpose design distinguishes LIRPs from traditional investment accounts like IRAs and 401(k)s.

A LIRP can greatly add tax diversification and guaranteed income layers to your retirement portfolio. Work with a fee-only financial planner or insurance agent to weigh the pros and cons relative to your specific financial situation and retirement goals.

The Two Main Types of Cash Value Life Insurance

There are a few varieties of permanent life insurance that build cash value. But two are most commonly used for retirement planning:

Whole Life Insurance
Universal Life Insurance

Whole Life offers lifetime coverage, fixed premiums, and a minimum guaranteed cash value growth rate. Your principal and earnings are locked in despite market swings.

With universal life insurance, premiums and cash value growth potential are flexible based on investment performance. This introduces both higher earnings potential and risk. You may need to pay additional premiums if growth is lower than expected to keep the death benefit in place.

Strategies for Withdrawing Cash Value in Retirement

If you purchase permanent life insurance for retirement planning, there are a few strategies to tap cash value:

Tax-Free Withdrawal

The most straightforward approach is tax-free withdrawals up to your cost basis starting at age 591⁄2. Taking out only your cost basis leaves earnings intact, extending cash value longevity.

Policy Loans

Borrowing from cash value is often the most efficient way to access funds without tax or early withdrawal penalties. Interest rates are generally low, but unpaid loans decrease your death benefit payout.

Income Riders

Some policies include guaranteed income riders for a fee. These pay out a portion of the death benefit annually while the insured lives, providing reliable retirement income.

Work with your insurance agent to model various withdrawal, loan, and income rider scenarios. Select the most efficient approach aligned with your financial plan.

Is Life Insurance Right for Your Retirement Plan?

Permanent life insurance isn’t right for everyone saving for retirement. But it can bridge savings gaps for high-net-worth individuals needing additional tax-deferred growth options.

Before purchasing a policy, ask yourself:

Have I exhausted tax-advantaged investing capacity in 401(k)s/IRAs?
Is my income high enough to sustain premium payments until death?
Am I interested in using life insurance to multiply the impact of estate planning?

If you answered yes, discuss options with a fee-only fiduciary financial planner. They can objectively weigh pros and cons and help craft an integrated strategy using life insurance to achieve your retirement goals.

The point is Retirement planning isn’t one-size-fits-all. Evaluate multiple income streams so you can retire on your terms. For some, life insurance cash value offers an overlooked way to secure the lifestyle they’ve worked hard for.

Pros and Cons section for using a life insurance retirement plan (LIRP):

The Pros of Life Insurance Retirement Plans

LIRPs provide several valuable benefits for retirement planning, including:

Tax-Deferred Growth – Cash value grows tax-deferred, enabling faster compounding than taxable accounts.
No Contribution Limits – You can overfund LIRPs with extra premium payments above the minimum without hitting contribution caps.
Tax-Free Income Options – Loans and withdrawals from cash value under certain conditions are tax-free. This enhances net gains.
Downside Risk Protection – Some LIRPs guarantee your principal and a minimum interest crediting rate even when markets decline.

The Cons of Life Insurance Retirement Plans

However, LIRPs also come with complexities to consider, like:

Higher Costs – LIRPs charge higher fees than typical investment products to fund the death benefit and insurance company operations.
Liquidity Limitations – It’s more challenging to access cash value funds than bank account or brokerage holdings due to withdrawal limits and processing time.
Risk of Losing Tax Benefits – If you drain cash value quickly via significant withdrawals or loans, remaining funds may get hit with taxes and surrender charges.
No Guaranteed Income Levels – Projected retirement income from cash value is based on assumptions. LIRP performance is not guaranteed to fully replace other lost income sources.

Carefully weigh all the pros and cons with a financial professional before funding an LIRP based on your situation. A diversified retirement portfolio is critical.

LIRP vs. Traditional Retirement Plans

Retirement planning today often includes a mix of tools like 401(k)s, IRAs, annuities, and taxable investment accounts. But life insurance retirement plans (LIRPs) function differently than these options in a few key ways:

LIRPs work differently than typical tax-advantaged retirement plans like 401(k)s and IRAs in a few key ways:

Growth Tax Treatment

LIRP cash value grows tax-deferred. You pay no taxes on interest earnings until you take withdrawals or loans. Traditional retirement accounts also grow tax-deferred (Roth accounts grow tax-free).

Contribution Limits

LIRPs have no annual contribution limits. You can fund premiums up to the maximums defined by the insurance carrier. Traditional retirement plans cap yearly contributions. For 2023, the 401(k) limit is $22,500 ($30,000 for age 50+).

Withdrawals and Required Minimum Distributions

LIRPs have no mandatory withdrawal requirements. You can take loans or withdrawals from cash value at your discretion after age 59 1⁄2. 401(k)s and traditional IRAs mandate withdrawals after age 72 to avoid tax penalties.

Legacy and Income Planning

LIRPs provide both guaranteed retirement income from cash value and a death benefit. When you die, beneficiaries receive a lump-sum payment. Traditional retirement accounts transfer leftover balances to heirs but don’t offer lifetime income sources.

The point is that LIRPs provide more flexibility and options for funding retirement and transferring wealth to beneficiaries. An integrated planning approach combining LIRPs with traditional tools can help secure your financial future in retirement.

Who Needs a Life Insurance Retirement Plan?

Who Can Benefit Most from an LIRP?

LIRPs can supplement retirement portfolios, but they’re not an ideal standalone savings tool for average retirement investors due to higher costs and complexity. LIRPs generally work best for:

High Earners

People who max out workplace retirement plan contributions plus IRA allowances can use LIRPs for additional tax-deferred savings capacity. Physicians, executives, and certain high-paid specialists often fall into this category. A financial professional can run projections to see if extra LIRP funding makes sense.

Individuals with Working Spouses Needing Income Replacement

If you’re married, and your spouse relies on your income, saving more to replace that income if you die early can secure your lifestyle. Due to the cash value savings component, LIRPs pay higher death benefits than regular term life insurance. This helps supplement lost wages.

Business Owners

Owners who want to fund buy-sell agreements tax-efficiently upon death can use LIRPs. Proceeds pass directly to named beneficiaries without probate. According to established agreements, funds are then available to transfer business equity to surviving partners.

Those Wanting to Multiply Wealth Transfer Impact

Anyone interested in maximizing legacy planning through optimized wealth transfers can benefit from LIRPs. You gain more control over asset distribution than traditional accounts while growing tax-advantaged savings.

Get personalized LIRP guidance from an independent fee-only financial planner based on your situation.

Conclusion

Life insurance retirement plans uniquely blend death benefit legacy planning with tax-advantaged savings growth.

Used strategically alongside workplace accounts, LIRPs provide supplemental funds to help secure your retirement.

Check Out: